Hotel-Condo Conceptually Attractive, but...
|
From an article published by the Associated Press, June
2005 Mike Schneider
"The hybrid concept of a luxury hotel that sells some of it units as
condominiums has become one of the most popular trends in the industry in recent
years. Condo-hotels in the past two or three years have expanded beyond
traditional markets in ski resorts or Hawaii and into other tourist destinations
such as Orlando and Las Vegas. Projects also are under construction in urban
centers like Atlanta, Chicago and New York, where the Plaza Hotel is being
converted.
The concept has risks for both the developer and the condo buyer.
Financial risks
The Securities and Exchange Commission considers the condo offering
a security if income and expenses
from the rental units are pooled and if a condo unit is sold with the explicit
expectation the buyer will earn money or derive tax benefits from it. If
the development is structured as a security, it can only be sold by a
securities broker and it is easier for an investor to sue the developer
under the SEC's anti-fraud rules, according to Los Angeles attorney Jim Butler.
Most developers choose not to sell
their projects as securities to avoid the SEC complications, so they are
prohibited from discussing the economic or tax benefits from a rental
arrangement or project on how much a condo unit can earn in rental income. Many
buyers make decisions without all the facts.
A developer typically has to come up with around 40 percent of the equity for a
traditional hotel; a condo-hotel development requires much less investment.
"If you're not allowed to
communicate revenue expectation, often times buyers are making a decision based
on incorrect information or overly optimistic information," a quote from
Mark Lunt, Ernst & Young in Miami.
|